Tree Angle: Part 1 – Too Wide

One of the most common issues that I run into in saddle fitting is that the angle of the tree (across several different models, styles and disciplines) is too wide.  In the saddle fit world often a rider will think that if a saddle is too wide they can just add a pad and it will fill in the difference.  While that can sometimes be the case more often it causes more severe pinching.  Let’s explore why.

First of all lets talk about what tree width is.  There are two factors width – the space between the panels or tree bars at the front of the saddle and angle – the angle of the tree arm from the top of the bar to the bottom in a western saddle and from the point where the panel starts (can vary slightly by brand/discipline) to the bottom of the tree on an english saddle.

english-western-angle
English and Western Tree Angle

 

So now that we have established what tree angle is let’s look at what it looks like on the horse when it is too wide.  If the angle of the tree is wider than the angle of the horse’s wither it puts a lot of stress and pressure on the muscles of the wither area.

 

tree-angle-too-wide
Examples of English and Western Tree that are Too Wide in the Angle

 

So why is tree angle too wide such a problem?  One of the most important things to remember in saddle fit is that the weight of the rider is going to sit on the horse’s back.  It is EXTREMELY important to have a tree that disperses this weight on the back.  An equine back in no way shape or form is designed to carry a rider.  The saddle allows the horse to do this in relative freedom and comfort.  When the tree angle is too wide it puts a lot of pressure on the withers that connect in the top of the wither. In addition, there is a trigger point in the wither that causes the horse to invert and life their head.  Between the muscles and the trigger point tree angle too wide is the number one cause of girthiness in horses.  It is a reaction to the tree being pulled down on the wither.

 

muscle-cross-section
Muscles and Trigger Point in Wither

 

Too add to the difficulty of fitting the tree angle the wither area is where we see the most amount of change in the mature horse through fitness.  Horse’s have no collar bone and therefore no shoulder joint and so how they are ridden can affect their conformation.  In a future post I am going to talk about spinal stabilization and global stabilization muscles but to summarize when the saddle pinches the wither and causes tightness in the neck and back it can actually push the ribs more downhill.  This results in a gap in front of the wither, rotation of sacrum joint (hunter’s bump) and compression of the joints at the base of the neck (ewe neck).  When the horse is comfortable and fit the shoulder pushes wider the rib cage elevates and the horse fills in in front of the wither and in the back.  This is how a saddle that does fit can then not fit as the horse gains or loses fitness.

 

rib-cage-lift
Rib Cage Alignment Changes Through Fitness

 

In a future post I want to further explore the muscles that interact with the saddle and how it affects equine confirmation.   However, I have been seeing a lot of tree angle issues recently and wanted to share this information for people to be able to assess this angle on their own equipment!

Fields marked with an * are required

8 Responses

  1. Ed Magonigal
    | Reply

    Great information!!!

  2. Kenneth Stillwell
    | Reply

    Excellent read. I look forward to upcoming articles from you. I have a saddle shop and have so many questions that go unanswered

  3. […] had initially planned to follow up my Tree Angle: Part 1 – Too Wide with a post about angles being narrow. Then, this week I had the opportunity to work with a lovely […]

  4. […] fit using a pad, we first have to recognize the unsolved issue. I am going to use an example of a tree angle too wide to illustrate how we would correct the fit using a […]

  5. […] fit, types of saddles, and a variety of pads and numnahs. He demonstrated that a saddle which was too wide for a horse increased the pressures exerted on the back. So regardless of which pad you want to use, […]

  6. […] A tree angle being too wide or tree width too narrow is the most common saddle fit error.  Most importantly: wider is NOT always better.  As a result it can cause focal pressure on the withers.  Symptoms: girthiness/cinchiness, grinding teeth, tossing head, irregularity in front, hollow back, inverted neck, sacrum out of alignment, white hairs.  To learn more about tree angle click: HERE […]

  7. […] For more information on how a horse changes under saddle please see this post. […]

  8. M. Brooks
    | Reply

    Excellent read, thank you.

Leave a Reply